Common App Applications Are Up
Williams Educational has the pleasure of working with all high school-aged students when considering the college process. I know that many seniors have already submitted college applications; yet they may be wondering whether this year’s headlines say anything about their chances. I am also aware of the conversations happening among younger students about the size of one’s college list.
Here’s what stood out to me in Common App’s November update. Through November 1, the number of students who applied rose just 1%, while the number of applications rose 6%. And at the most selective colleges in the report, applications rose 14%. That distinction matters. Students submitted more applications per person on average, and application growth was especially strong at colleges that admit fewer than 25% of applicants.

At Williams Educational Consultants, we strongly encourage students to give every college on their list a clear purpose. Common App submissions are up, and it’s easy to feel pressure to apply to more schools. Before adding one, ask: If I’m admitted and the cost works for my family, would I seriously consider going?
A balanced list includes foundation schools, where admission appears likely and the cost is realistic, target schools, where the student’s academic profile aligns with that of recently admitted students, and reach schools, where admission is less predictable. To build that list, students should understand their own transcript and research how each college evaluates grades, course rigor, and other application materials. Check the requirements for the intended major or program, too.
For most students, we recommend applying to no more than 12 colleges. A longer list may make sense for students applying to BS/MD programs, navigating athletic recruitment, or looking for a specialized program or other specific fit. In those cases, each additional application should serve a purpose the student can explain.
If your senior applied this fall
Check your portals and keep your remaining applications moving. This is the advice I’m giving my seniors right now. Make sure each college has received what it needs, and track any remaining application, scholarship, and financial aid deadlines. If an early decision is still pending, keep working on the Regular Decision applications you’d want to submit if that first-choice school doesn’t come through.
If you’re considering adding a college, ask your student one question: Would I be happy to go there if I got in and the cost worked for our family? If the answer is yes, it may be worth a closer look. That’s especially true if most of the schools already on the list are reaches.
If your student will apply in a future season
Start early enough to find colleges your student genuinely likes across a range of admission chances. Go ahead and include the dream school. Give just as much attention to the colleges where admission looks more likely and the cost is realistic. I want students to be able to name something they’re excited about at those schools, too. It might be a major they can explore, a campus that felt right when they visited, or a program that gives them hands-on experience in a field they’re curious about.
As you build the list, check requirements for your student’s intended major and application year. A university’s overall admit rate can tell you only so much if your student is applying to a more selective program. Check testing policies directly with each college, and use its net price calculator early enough to have a real conversation about affordability.
The question I’d come back to as a family is simple: If the most selective schools on this list say no, would my student still have choices they’d be excited about and we could afford? If you can say yes, you’ve built a college list that can serve your student well through decision season.
If you’d like help reviewing your senior’s remaining options or building a college list for a future application season, reach out to Williams Educational Consultants. I’d love to hear what your student is looking for and help your family choose wisely.



Comments